Here is how Moneything compares to the similar P2P platforms that I invest in, together with real-life results:
|Platform||Link||Target Rate (%)||My XIRR (%)||Status||Live Rating|
|Review||Up to 16%||-7.9% (estimate)||CLOSED||1.5/5|
|Review||Up to 7.2%||7.23%||OPEN||4/5|
|Review||Up to 11%||5.40%||OPEN||4/5|
|Review||Up to 13%||1.04% (estimate)||CLOSED||2.5/5|
|Review||Up to 8%||1.89%||OPEN||3.5/5|
|Review||Up to 8%||TBC||OPEN||3/5|
What is Moneything?
Moneything is a relatively new P2P lender. It opened its doors for business in 2015. They offer a wide variety of loans across a different range of assets. Initially there were many smaller loans which dealt with physical assets such as stock, cars and jewelry. In more recent times more property bridging and development loans have appeared on the platform. The larger investor base no doubt creating demand for larger projects.
This is a keenly contested segment of the market, with other P2P lenders such as Funding Secure offering the same type of loans, both in size and asset types. Moneything are competitive on the rates they offer. Most loans are 12%, with some at 11% and 13%. There are also cashback offers available should loans not fill quickly enough. Moneything loans all operate in the same way, Interest is paid monthly, with the capital being repaid at the end of the loan.
Here is a table which details Moneything’s features:
|Advertised Returns||Up to 13%|
|Loan Security||Property, Debenture, Assets|
|Cash Drag||Dependent on loan|
|Available in ISA?||Yes|
|Active on forum?||Yes|
How is the Moneything wind-down progressing?
The December 2019 decision to close the site to new investments and wind down existing loans was not surprising. Volumes had dried up, perhaps due to increased competition and lender apathy. To Moneything’s credit, instead of pursuing risky loans (such as Funding Secure) or simply trying to work until the money ran out, shutting the doors helps protect investor interest. As we have seen in the Collateral, Lendy and Funding Secure procedures, administration is an expensive option. As costs to the administrator are paid before recoveries, lenders lose out.
As of September 2020, and from my perspective only, the wind-down procedure has been slow. Some of this is to be expected due to the recent pandemic. There have been some recoveries over the past six months, amounting to roughly 10% of my balance. The other 90% is still outstanding.
The XIRR in my calculations assumes a 75% recovery rate in funds outstanding. This is only a rough guess and only includes capital and not accrued interest. As of 2021 it (perhaps unsurprisingly) appears that some loans are proving to be problematic. My recovery rate may prove to be too optimistic.
An adminstrators proposal appeared in February 2021. This provides confirmation of a few things – that administration is a slow and costly procedure.
Are Moneything profitable?
Moneything is a trading name of Moneything Capital Limited. This has been incorporated since 2004. The last accounts were filed on 18 December 2019 for the period of 12 months to 31 March 2019. The abbreviated accounts show a net asset position of £127,206, although retained earnings fell by approximately £44,000. Cash at bank had also declined sharply from £485,000 to £135,000.
A charge appeared recently over the company assets which presumably is for borrowing for working capital. This is not such a good thing for investors. The charge is from a company called Rapid Finance which presumably is a lender of last resort at high interest rates, and if the wind-down does not go as planned repayments could rank behind this charge.
Your account can be funded via bank transfer (min £100, although there is a £1 minimum on loans). New loans appear on the platform, usually with some advance notice and initial bid limits, since any non-property loans tend to be very popular. The decisions regarding the product is quite simple – there is no auto-invest or black-box product. This means you must select your loans yourself. This feature is bound to delight some, but not others.
Selecting the loans is easy – simply click on to the loan, read the accompanying details and pledge your amount. Interest is paid once the loan goes live and is paid monthly, with capital being repaid at the end. As already remarked, more riskier loans have started to appear on the platform such as second charge loans and loans contingent on developments. Thus it is not a case of automatically investing into everything you see.
Like most platforms, Moneything has a secondary market where you can sell loans without charge. Unlike other platforms it is not possible to discount your loans and they are only offered at par.
How are funds protected?
There is no provision fund, or any other feature designed to compensate investors in times of loss. Instead Moneything seeks to lower the risks by only using conservative valuations. An example of this is current valuations instead of the common Gross Development Value (GDV). This is something that has seen loans on other platforms go bad, because the figure is based on multiple uncertain factors.
Moneything Review: Pros
There are several things to like about Moneything:
Range of Asset Types: Moneything offers a genuine range of different assets to invest in, from cars to business assets. Property has taken over as the dominant class on the platform, but it is still possible to gain exposure on the secondary market.
High Interest Rates: There is little variation on the interest rates which are high: most loans pay over 11%.
Good Communications: The site is easy to navigate. Where updates have been required on loans, they have been fairly comprehensive even if the news was bad. Transparency is better than on some platforms, for example related loans are disclosed.
Moneything Review: Cons
There are also several things to dislike about Moneything:
Difficult to diversify: There are not too many loans available on the secondary market, meaning it would be difficult for a new user to create a diverse portfolio.
No discounting on secondary market: This means it may be difficult to exit a loan if it has become slightly impaired.
Some cash drag: Some of the bigger loans can take months to fill due to their size.
Risk creeping in: Several property loans have gone bad in the past year, leaving lenders with likely losses.
Risk Drift: A new direction or temporary blip?
One of the bigger concerns is the taking on of bigger loans which have gone on to default. Without revealing specifics of these loans, many were to fund rather speculative developments which went on to fail. The story is quite familiar in that the developer simply ran out of cash. This leaves lenders in a difficult position, which is either to sell an uncompleted development, or to provide the additional finance and sell it then. In the first case, there may be few takers for the property (in which case the price either keeps on going down or it goes to auction), and in the second case, losses may be realised.
It is understandable why this happened. Moneything now have loaned £90m and this wouldn’t have happened if they kept on loaning on small value items. By incorporating property, several millions can be loaned at once. Unfortunately these come at bigger risk and lenders bear the brunt of that. It is rather notable that the ‘no to GDV’ did not save lenders from losses.
Most notably there have been loans put forward by Moneything that have been so poor that they could not attain the funding required. When the platform has nothing to lose this type of thing happens.
At present the rate of loans has decreased, and many of these are still for property. On one hand, many of the defaulted loans appear to be handled well. Action is taken fairly quickly unlike on some platforms where nothing is done for years (in the hope that divine intervention makes the developer work again), but this does not mask the fact there will be losses for lenders.
My Moneything Investing Strategy
With only a self-select product, the strategy has to be to choose your own loans. For a new lender, this may not be that straightforward. The only loans available at this point are the ones on the secondary market and these are mainly property. With this in mind it may take some patience to build up a good-sized exposure. My rules are:
Modest investment size: Keep your investment to only what you can afford to lose.
Read the loan documents: Despite the very similar interest rates, in my view the quality of loans differ quite a lot. Examine the possibility of the exit should things go wrong. If something looks too good to be true, it probably is.
Scan the secondary market: Regular scans of the secondary market here are good, because once in a while someone will be selling a non-property loan, for example one backed by cars.
Avoid second charge loans/additional tranches: These are quite rare on the platform but I would still give them a wide berth, neither pay a massive premium over standard loans.
MONEYTHING REVIEW: CONCLUSION
Moneything is a relatively new peer-to-peer site that offers high rates of interest across a wide variety of asset classes. This gives it quite a bit in common with Funding Secure, but the way the platform has dealt with some of its problematic loans gives me a far better impression of the competence of its management. Currently extra investment is being held up here due to a lack of suitable loans.
Disclaimer: This Moneything review represents my own opinions and should not be substituted for investment advice. Please research before you invest with any firm. Typically P2P investments are not covered by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) in the way bank deposits are, and there are no guarantees that you will receive the returns advertised (or even a return at all).